-
iestinstrument
Correlation Between Particle Size and Mechanical Properties of Silicon-Carbon Anode Materials
Abstract
Anode particle size and crushing strength are inversely correlated: smaller particles consistently achieve higher crushing strength (MPa, resistance per unit area) while larger particles generate higher absolute crushing force (N, total force to fracture). This counter-intuitive relationship holds across silicon-carbon (SiC), hard carbon (HC), and resin carbon (RC) anode materials prepared by the same process. Single-particle compression tests of silicon-carbon (SC), hard carbon (HC), and resin carbon (RC) anode materials showed the same pattern within each tested material: larger particles required a higher crushing force, whereas smaller particles had a higher calculated crushing strength. Measurements were made with the IEST SPFT2000 single particle mechanical testing system following GB/T 43091-2023. At 8.5 µm, the reported crushing strengths were 1,633 MPa for SC2, 968 MPa for RC, 339 MPa for SC1, 184 MPa for HC1, and 161 MPa for HC2. The results show that particle size affects crushing strength, but its influence is constrained by the material’s intrinsic microstructure.
1. Introduction
To simultaneously optimize electrode compaction density, slurry processability, conductive network continuity, electrode sheet resistance, and electrode pore structure for electrolyte transport, and to balance cycle life and fast-charging performance, battery material manufacturers typically prepare anode particles across multiple size grades. The differences in the mechanical properties of particles among different size grades affect their resistance to fracture during calendering and pulverization during cycling. In this study, the IEST SPFT2000 Single Particle Force Properties Tester was used to measure crushing force and calculate crushing strength for two size grades of each silicon–carbon, hard carbon, and resin carbon sample. The comparisons provide data for evaluating particle size grades and candidate anode formulations.
2. Equipment and Method
2.1 Test Equipment: IEST SPFT2000 Single Particle Force Tester
Single-particle compression tests were performed with the IEST SPFT2000 Single Particle Force Properties Tester (Figure 1), a dedicated instrument for single particle mechanical testing of battery active materials in accordance with Chinese national standard GB/T 43091-2023. The system integrates a high-precision load cell, motorized compression stage, and optical bottom-view imaging system that enables particle centering and diameter verification before each test.
Figure 1. IEST SPFT2000 (a) instrument; (b) compression test mode — particle positioned between indenters, load and displacement recorded simultaneously to derive crushing force and crushing strength; (c) bottom-view image of a single particle.
2.2 Test Samples
- Two silicon-carbon samples, SC1 and SC2, were tested at 4.5 ± 0.5 µm and 8.5 ± 0.5 µm.
- Two hard carbon samples, HC1 and HC2, were tested at 4.5 ± 0.5 µm and 8.5 ± 0.5 µm.
- One resin carbon sample, RC, was tested at 8.5 ± 0.5 µm and 15 ± 0.5 µm.
SC1 and SC2 were described as being prepared by the same process, as were HC1 and HC2.
2.3 Test Procedure
Dispersed sample suspensions were drop-cast onto glass slides. Five particles were tested for each size grade of each material. The optical imaging system was used to check particle diameter and position the particle in the test area before compression. Crushing force was obtained from the force–displacement curve, and crushing strength was calculated using Equation (1).
Equation (1):
\[p_c = \alpha \times 1000 \times \frac{F_k}{\pi \cdot d^2}\]
where:
\( p_c \) — compressive strength, in MPa;
\( \alpha \) — calculation coefficient, taken as 2.48, as specified in GB/T 43091-2023;
\( F_k \) — crushing force, in mN;
\( d \) — particle size (diameter), in \(\mu\)m.
Key Definitions
Crushing force (N): the minimum external compressive load required to fracture a single particle. Increases with particle size because larger particles have greater load-bearing cross-sectional area and volume.
Crushing strength (MPa): a particle’s resistance to fracture under compression after accounting for its size, calculated from the measured crushing force and particle diameter using Equation (1). GB/T 43091-2023 (Test method for compressive strength of powder) refers to this quantity as the compressive strength of powder.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1 Crushing Force within Each Material
Figure 2 shows the crushing force comparison across three anode material types at different particle sizes. The result is consistent across all materials: crushing force increases with increasing particle size for silicon-carbon SC and hard carbon HC (8.5 µm particles show significantly higher crushing force than 4.5 µm), and for resin carbon RC (15 µm particles show significantly higher crushing force than 8.5 µm).
Figure 2. Crushing force at two particle size grades for SC1, SC2, HC1, HC2, and RC.
| Material | Particle Size (µm) | Crushing Force Trend | Crushing Strength (MPa) Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
| SC1 (Silicon-carbon) | 4.5 → 8.5 | ↑ Increases | ↓ Decreases |
| SC2 (Silicon-carbon) | 4.5 → 8.5 | ↑ Increases | ↓ Decreases |
| HC1 (Hard carbon) | 4.5 → 8.5 | ↑ Increases | ↓ Decreases |
| HC2 (Hard carbon) | 4.5 → 8.5 | ↑ Increases | ↓ Decreases |
| RC (Resin carbon) | 8.5 → 15 | ↑ Increases | ↓ Decreases |
| At 8.5 µm (same particle size): RC = 968 MPa; SC2 = 1,632 MPa; SC1 = 339 MPa — intrinsic microstructure determines absolute crushing strength ceiling regardless of particle size | |||
| Material | Particle Size (μm) |
Mean Crushing Force (mN) |
Mean Crushing Strength (MPa) |
|---|---|---|---|
| SC1 | 4.5 / 8.5 | 12 / 31 | 451 / 339 |
| SC2 | 4.5 / 8.5 | 72 / 149 | 2,808 / 1,633 |
| HC1 | 4.5 / 8.5 | 5 / 17 | 208 / 184 |
| HC2 | 4.5 / 8.5 | 7 / 15 | 261 / 161 |
| RC | 8.5 / 15 | 89 / 169 | 968 / 593 |
3.2 Crushing Strength within Each Material
Crushing strength represents compressive resistance per unit cross-sectional area — a size-normalized, intrinsic measure of particle mechanical performance. Figure 3 shows the opposite pattern for calculated crushing strength: within each tested material, the smaller size grade had the higher value. Silicon-carbon SC and hard carbon HC both show higher mean crushing strength at 4.5 µm compared to 8.5 µm; resin carbon RC shows higher crushing strength at 8.5 µm compared to 15 µm.
Figure 3. Calculated crushing strength at two particle sizes for SC1, SC2, HC1, HC2, and RC.
Why do smaller particles have higher crushing strength? During granulation and sintering of anode materials, smaller particles achieve higher densification. Smaller particle volume means shorter diffusion distances during sintering, more complete pore elimination, fewer residual internal micropores, fewer primary cracks, and lower structural defect density overall. Because crack propagation and fracture initiation in ceramic-like particles originate at internal defects, a particle with fewer and smaller defects requires higher stress to initiate fracture — resulting in higher crushing strength per unit area.
This relationship has a direct practical implication for long-cycle battery formulation design: small-particle anode materials buffer the internal stress generated by lithiation volume expansion more effectively, and are more resistant to the particle fracture and pulverization that causes capacity fade during cycling. This is precisely why long-cycle power battery formulations preferentially incorporate small-particle-grade materials — not because they withstand higher total force, but because they have higher intrinsic per-unit-area compressive resistance that preserves particle integrity during repeated lithiation stress.
3.3 Comparison at the Same Particle Size
Comparing crushing strength at the same particle size (8.5 µm) across the three material types reveals that intrinsic microstructure — not particle size — is the dominant factor setting the upper limit of particle mechanical performance:
- SC2 (silicon-carbon): 1,632 MPa — the highest among all tested materials at 8.5 µm, exceeding both hard carbon grades.
- Resin carbon (RC): 968 MPa — intermediate strength at 8.5 µm.
- SC1 (silicon-carbon): 339 MPa — substantially lower than SC2 despite identical particle size and the same stated process, indicating that the specific carbonization conditions, silicon dispersion state, or precursor quality within the “same process” range produce significantly different microstructural outcomes.
- HC1 and HC2 (hard carbon): both fall between RC and SC1 in crushing strength at 8.5 µm.
The SC1 vs. SC2 comparison at the same particle size is particularly instructive: two silicon-carbon materials described as “same process” differ in crushing strength by nearly 5× (339 MPa vs. 1,632 MPa). This confirms that particle size is a secondary modulator of crushing strength — the primary determinant is the intrinsic microstructure established during material synthesis, including carbonization degree, carbon shell continuity, internal porosity, and primary defect density. Particle size can only adjust crushing strength within the range defined by the material’s fixed microstructural properties; it cannot overcome a fundamentally weak microstructure.
This finding has direct relevance to anode particle size optimization for cycling stability: selecting a smaller particle size grade of a microstructurally inferior material may improve its crushing strength relative to its own larger grade, but will not match the performance of a microstructurally superior material at the same particle size. Effective formulation design must address both dimensions — material microstructure and particle size grading — rather than optimizing either in isolation.
4. Conclusions
Using the IEST SPFT2000 Single Particle Force Tester (GB/T 43091-2023), this study systematically establishes the particle size — mechanical property relationships for silicon-carbon, hard carbon, and resin carbon anode materials:
- Crushing force increases with particle size (positive correlation): larger particles have greater effective load-bearing cross-sectional area and volume, requiring higher total external force for fracture. This trend is consistent across silicon-carbon (4.5 µm vs. 8.5 µm), hard carbon (4.5 µm vs. 8.5 µm), and resin carbon (8.5 µm vs. 15 µm).
- Crushing strength decreases with particle size (inverse correlation): smaller particles densify more completely during sintering, leaving fewer internal defects and microcracks, resulting in higher per-unit-area compressive resistance. Small-particle anode materials better resist lithiation-induced internal stress and particle pulverization during cycling — explaining why long-cycle power battery formulations preferentially use small-particle-grade materials.
- Intrinsic material microstructure sets the crushing strength ceiling: at equal particle size (8.5 µm), SC2 achieves 1,632 MPa, resin carbon RC 968 MPa, and SC1 only 339 MPa — confirming that carbonization quality and microstructural density are the primary determinants of particle mechanical performance, with particle size modulating strength within material-defined limits.
Single particle mechanical testing using the SPFT2000 provides a quantitative, standardized method to characterize the particle size — mechanical property relationship in anode powders. This data directly guides anode powder granulation process control, particle size grading classification, and multi-grade formulation blending design — offering a low-cost route to simultaneously improving anode material processability and long-cycle stability. Note: the trends reported here apply to materials prepared by the same process; special formulations or atypical manufacturing processes may produce deviations from these general rules.
5. References
[1] GB/T 43091-2023. Powder Crushing Strength Test Method [S]. China National Standard, 2023.
6. FAQs: Anode Particle Size and Mechanical Properties
6.1 What is the relationship between particle size and crushing strength in anode materials?
For anode materials prepared by the same process, smaller particles show higher crushing strength (MPa, per unit area), while larger particles have higher absolute crushing force (N, total fracture load) but lower crushing strength. This inverse correlation is consistent across silicon-carbon, hard carbon, and resin carbon materials tested with the IEST SPFT2000 per GB/T 43091-2023.
6.2 Why do smaller anode particles have higher crushing strength than larger particles?
Smaller particles densify more completely during sintering, leaving fewer internal micropores, primary cracks, and structural defects. Because fracture initiates at these defects, particles with fewer and smaller defects require higher stress to fracture — resulting in higher crushing strength per unit area.
6.3 How does anode particle size selection affect battery cycling stability?
Small-particle anode materials better resist the internal stress from lithiation volume expansion (especially important for silicon-based anodes with up to 300% volume change). Higher crushing strength means less particle pulverization and SEI re-formation during cycling, which is why long-cycle battery formulations preferentially use small-particle-grade materials.
6.4 What determines the absolute crushing strength ceiling for anode particles?
Intrinsic material microstructure is the primary determinant. At the same particle size (8.5 µm), SC2 achieves 1,632 MPa, resin carbon 968 MPa, and SC1 only 339 MPa — confirming that carbonization quality and defect density set the ceiling, with particle size only modulating strength within that range.
6.5 How does single-particle crushing strength impact battery performance?
Higher crushing strength prevents particles from pulverizing under electrode calendering pressures and during cyclic lithiation-induced volume expansion. Preventing particle cracking avoids exposing fresh surfaces, suppressing continuous SEI growth and active lithium loss.
6.6 What is single-particle mechanical testing and why is it useful?
Single-particle testing compresses individual particles between flat indenters until fracture, recording force-displacement data to calculate crushing force (N) and crushing strength (MPa). This test, standardized in GB/T 43091-2023, enables direct comparison of different particle size grades, materials, and supplier batches — guiding granulation control, particle size grading, and multi-grade formulation design.
Contact Us
If you are interested in our products and want to know more details, please leave a message here, we will reply you as soon as we can.


