-
iestinstrument
Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT) Analysis for Resolving Overlapping Electrochemical Processes in EIS
Abstract
Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT) analysis is a mathematical deconvolution technique that converts electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) data from the frequency domain into a time-domain distribution function \(\gamma(\tau)\)— separating overlapping electrochemical processes into distinct peaks based on their characteristic relaxation time constants \(\tau\). Unlike Equivalent Circuit Model (ECM) fitting, DRT analysis requires no prior assumption about the circuit topology: it deconvolves the full EIS spectrum into a series of peaks, where each peak corresponds to one independent electrochemical process (ohmic resistance, SEI layer, charge transfer, or solid-state diffusion), and the peak area directly represents the impedance contribution of that process. However, recovering a DRT spectrum from measured impedance data is an ill-posed inverse problem and therefore requires numerical regularization. Tikhonov regularization is commonly used to balance agreement with the measured data against smoothness of the reconstructed distribution and to limit noise-induced artifacts. DRT peak positions and integrated amplitudes can help distinguish contributions associated with interfacial films, charge-transfer kinetics, and mass transport. An electrochemical workstation equipped with integrated DRT analysis — such as the IEST ERT7008 series — enables automated impedance decomposition with peak area integration, reducing data processing time and eliminating ECM dependency.
1. Why DRT Can Resolve Overlapping Features in EIS Spectra
Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is widely used in battery research and quality control to characterize internal electrochemical mechanisms. However, visual inspection of a Nyquist plot has limited resolving power: a single apparent semicircle may contain contributions from multiple electrochemical processes with similar relaxation time constants, such as surface-film response and charge transfer.
Equivalent Circuit Model (ECM) fitting addresses this by assuming a circuit topology — for example, a second-order RQ network — and extracting parameter values through nonlinear least-squares regression. However, ECM fitting has two inherent weaknesses: (1) the circuit topology must be specified before fitting, introducing model bias; and (2) different cell chemistries and aging states produce visually distinct impedance features, making a single ECM topology inadequate across sample sets.
DRT analysis circumvents these limitations. As a pure mathematical deconvolution technique, DRT requires no prior assumption about circuit topology [3]. It converts the frequency-domain EIS spectrum into a distribution of relaxation times \(\gamma(\tau)\), producing a DRT spectrum in which each electrochemical process appears as a discrete peak centered at its characteristic time constant \(\tau\). The Nyquist-ECM-DRT relationship is illustrated in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Comparison of Nyquist, ECM, and DRT representations of an impedance response.
2. What is Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT)?
Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT) is a mathematical transformation of EIS impedance data \(Z(\omega)\) into a continuous distribution function \(\gamma(\tau)\) that represents the density of electrochemical relaxation processes as a function of the time constant τ. Each electrochemical process in a real battery system — SEI ion transport, charge transfer, solid-state diffusion — relaxes on a characteristic timescale determined by its RC product (\(\tau\) = RC). The DRT function \(\gamma(\tau)\) maps the amplitude of each relaxation contribution as a function of \(\tau\), producing a spectrum of peaks in the time domain.
The mathematical relationship between the impedance spectrum \(Z(\omega)\) and the DRT function \(\gamma(\tau)\) is:
DRT Core Equation
\[
Z(\omega) = R_\infty + \int_0^\infty \frac{y(t)}{1 + j\omega t} \, dt
\]
where: \(\gamma(\tau)\) = DRT distribution function (the target spectrum) | \(R_{\infty}\) = ohmic resistance | (\(\tau\) = RC = relaxation time constant | \Z(\omega\) = angular frequency | j = imaginary unit
In this formulation, \(\gamma(\tau)d\tau\) represents the impedance contribution associated with relaxation times between \(\tau\) and τ + d\tau\). Accordingly, when impedance is expressed in ohms and relaxation time in seconds, \(\gamma(\tau)\) has units of Ω·s⁻¹.
The key distinction from ECM analysis is that DRT analysis does not require the user to specify a circuit topology before performing the inversion. Peaks, shoulders, or broad features in the reconstructed DRT spectrum indicate relaxation-time regions containing significant impedance contributions. These features can help distinguish responses that overlap in a Nyquist plot.
The resistance contribution associated with a selected DRT feature is obtained by integrating γ(τ) over the corresponding relaxation-time interval:
\(R_{\text{process}} = \int_{\tau_1}^{\tau_2} \gamma(\tau) d\tau\)
This integrated resistance may be compared with the corresponding resistance obtained from ECM fitting, provided that the selected DRT feature and circuit element represent the same electrochemical response.
3. Tikhonov Regularization and DRT Deconvolution Algorithms
Computing the DRT function \(\gamma(\tau)\) from measured EIS data is an ill-posed inverse problem — meaning that small perturbations in the input data (noise, discrete sampling) can produce arbitrarily large perturbations in the recovered distribution. Three characteristics of real EIS measurements make this inversion numerically challenging:
- Discrete frequency sampling: EIS measures impedance only at a finite number of frequency points, not as a continuous spectrum, limiting the information available for mathematical inversion.
- Measurement noise: Instrumental noise, environmental disturbances, and cell variability introduce errors into each impedance data point, and these errors may be amplified during the inversion calculation.
- Overlapping relaxation responses: Processes occurring over similar timescales produce overlapping impedance contributions, making them difficult to separate reliably.
Regularization algorithms address these challenges by introducing a smoothness constraint on the reconstructed distribution \(\gamma(\tau)\), balancing spectral resolution against stability [1, 2]:
| Method | Principle | Key Parameter | Advantage | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tikhonov Regularization | Adds a penalty term \(\lambda \|\nabla \gamma\|^2\) to the cost function, suppressing noise amplification and constrain excessive variation in (\gamma(\tau)\) | Regularization parameter \(\lambda\), which controls the balance between fitting accuracy and spectral smoothness. It may be selected by L-curve analysis or cross-validation | Widely used and effective for stabilizing DRT inversion in the presence of measurement noise | \(\lambda\) selection requires judgment |
| Richardson-Lucy Deconvolution | Iterative Bayesian algorithm that maximizes the likelihood of the recovered distribution given the noisy data | Number of iterations. Additional iterations may sharpen the recovered features but can also amplify noise | Can produce a non-negative reconstructed distribution | May converge slowly and become sensitive to noise when too many iterations are used |
| Ridge Regression | L2 regularization applied to the discretized inversion problem; closely related to Tikhonov in discrete form | Ridge parameter \(\alpha\), which controls the strength of the coefficient penalty | Straightforward to implement and numerically stable | Depending on the selected penalty, closely spaced or weak features may be oversmoothed |
Tikhonov regularization is one of the most widely used approaches for battery EIS deconvolution. Its regularization parameter \(\lambda\) controls the trade-off between stability and resolution: increasing \(\lambda\) suppresses noise but may merge nearby features, whereas decreasing \(\lambda\) preserves finer structure but may introduce artifacts. Optimal λ selection, typically performed using L-curve analysis or generalized cross-validation, is critical for producing physically meaningful DRT spectra.
Figure 2. Effect of Tikhonov regularization parameter \(\lambda\) on DRT spectrum quality.
4. DRT Peak Interpretation: Relating Time Constants to Electrochemical Processes
A DRT spectrum separates impedance contributions according to their characteristic relaxation times. Peaks, shoulders, and broad distributions can therefore help identify electrochemical responses that overlap in a Nyquist plot. However, the interpretation of a DRT feature depends on the cell chemistry, state of charge (SOC), state of health (SOH), temperature, measurement frequency range, and data quality.
| DRT Region | Characteristic Time Range | Possible Electrochemical Assignment | Related ECM Representation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Series-resistance term | Not assigned to a finite relaxation time | High-frequency series resistance, commonly including contributions from the electrolyte, current collectors, electrical contacts, and external connections | \(R_{\infty}\) or \(R_0\) |
| Short relaxation times | (\(\tau\) < 10-5 s | Fast interfacial, contact, or surface-film responses; the specific assignment depends on the battery system and measurement bandwidth | High-frequency R ∥ C or R ∥ CPE element, where applicable |
| Intermediate-to-short relaxation times | 10−5–10−3 s | Surface-film or interphase-related responses, including possible solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) contributions | \(R_{SEI} \| CPE_{SEI}\) or \(R_{film} \| CPE_{film}\) |
| Intermediate relaxation times | 10−3–10−1 s | Electrode–electrolyte interfacial kinetics, including possible charge-transfer and double-layer-related responses | \(R_{ct} \parallel CPE_{dl}\) |
| Long relaxation times | (\(\tau\) > 10-1 s | Mass-transport and diffusion-related responses, including electrolyte transport, porous-electrode effects, and solid-state diffusion | Finite-length or semi-infinite diffusion element |
The relationship between DRT features and ECM elements can often be correlated. One apparent semicircle in a Nyquist plot may contain several overlapping DRT features, while one broad DRT feature may include contributions from more than one physical process. When an ECM has been independently validated, its fitted parameters can be compared with DRT peak positions and integrated resistances to support process assignment.
Figure 3. Relationship between Nyquist features and DRT spectrum.
5. DRT Plotting Conventions and Coordinate Transformations
DRT spectra may be plotted against either relaxation time \(\tau\) or the logarithm of relaxation time. These representations describe the same impedance response, but the distribution function must be transformed together with the horizontal coordinate.
- Method A — Relaxation time on a logarithmic axis: The original relaxation-time values, τ, are plotted on a logarithmically scaled x-axis. Peak positions are read directly in seconds.
- Method B — Log-transformed relaxation time on a linear axis: The horizontal coordinate is transformed to $\log_{10}(\tau/s)$ and plotted on a linear axis. For example, a value of $-3$ corresponds to $\tau = 10^{-3}$ s.
Both displays describe the same impedance response, and the resistance associated with a given feature is unchanged. However, the ordinate must be converted together with the abscissa. A distribution defined per unit \(\tau\), \(\gamma(\tau)\) in \(\Omega \cdot s^{-1}\), becomes \(\gamma(\ln \tau) = \tau \cdot \gamma(\tau)\) in \(\Omega\) when the horizontal variable is \(\ln \tau\) (or \(\log_{10}\tau\), up to a constant factor of \(\ln 10\)). Peak heights and apparent peak shapes therefore differ between the two displays, and the area under a peak equals the resistance only when the ordinate and the integration variable match. Method B is frequently used in published literature; Method A may be preferred in software implementations where axis transformation is applied automatically.
Figure 4. Two equivalent displays of the same DRT dataset: relaxation time \(\tau\) shown on a logarithmic axis and \(\log_{10}(\tau/\text{s})\) shown on a linear axis.
6. IEST ERT7008: Integrated EIS-DRT Analysis with an Electrochemical Workstation
The impedance contribution of each electrochemical process equals the area under its corresponding DRT peak. Mathematically, this area is the integral of \(\gamma(\tau)\) over the time constant range associated with that peak:
Peak Area = Process Impedance (Ω)
\[
R_{\text{process}} = \int_{\tau_1}^{\tau_2} \gamma(\tau) \, d(\ln \tau)
\]
where \([\tau_1, \tau_2]\) defines the relaxation-time range selected for the feature of interest. For discretized DRT data, the integral can be approximated using a weighted numerical sum:
\(R_{\text{process}} \approx \sum_i \gamma_i \Delta\tau_i\)
where \(\gamma_i\) is the reconstructed DRT density at the i-th relaxation-time point and \(\Delta\tau_i\) is the corresponding interval width. Including the interval width is particularly important when the relaxation-time points are not uniformly spaced.
When a DRT feature has been assigned to an SEI-related response, integrating \(\gamma(\tau)\) over the corresponding relaxation-time range provides an estimate of its resistance contribution. Similarly, integration of a feature assigned to charge transfer provides an estimate that may be compared with \(R_{ct}\) obtained from an appropriate ECM. These comparisons depend on the validity of the feature assignment and the selected ECM.
The IEST ERT7008 Electrochemical Performance Analyzer integrates DRT analysis into its analysis software, enabling the complete EIS-to-DRT workflow within the instrument interface. Key capabilities include:
- Automated EIS-to-DRT processing: DRT spectra are computed from acquired EIS data without manual data export or external software, reducing analysis time from hours to minutes.
- Interactive range selection and integration: Users select the relaxation-time range associated with a DRT feature, and the software calculates its integrated impedance contribution.
- Tikhonov regularization: The software applies Tikhonov regularization to stabilize DRT reconstruction and supports evaluation of the regularization parameter.
- Direct comparison with ECM results: Integrated DRT resistance contributions can be compared with resistance values obtained from ECM fitting, supporting cross-checking between distribution-based and circuit-based interpretations.
Figure 5. IEST ERT7008 DRT analysis software: integrated EIS-to-DRT conversion with interactive peak selection, automated numerical integration for impedance extraction, and Tikhonov regularization with parameter guidance.
7. DRT vs. ECM: When to Use Each Approach
DRT analysis and ECM fitting are complementary analytical methods. Understanding when each approach is most appropriate guides experimental design and data interpretation:
- Use DRT for exploratory analysis: When studying a new cell chemistry, aging mechanism, or degradation mode, DRT analysis reveals relaxation-time regions containing significant impedance contributions without requiring a predefined circuit topology. The number, position, width, and integrated resistance of stable DRT features can help guide subsequent ECM development.
- Use ECM for model-based parameter estimation: Once a circuit topology is selected and validated, ECM fitting provides parameters such as resistance, capacitance, constant-phase-element coefficients, and dispersion exponents. These parameters can be tracked across cycling conditions, temperature, SOC values, or cell populations.
- Use DRT for degradation diagnosis: Tracking the evolution of DRT feature positions, widths, and integrated resistance can help distinguish how impedance contributions evolve during aging.
8. Practical Recommendations for DRT Analysis in Battery R&D
- Validate the EIS data before inversion: Check measurement stability, repeatability, frequency coverage, and signal quality. Regularization can stabilize the inversion but cannot correct fundamentally invalid or non-stationary impedance data.
- Use a consistent regularization procedure: Select λ using a documented numerical criterion and evaluate the resulting spectrum against residual behavior and feature stability. Features that appear only within a narrow range of λ values should be interpreted cautiously.
- Validate feature assignments: Interpret DRT features in the context of cell chemistry, SOC, temperature, aging condition, and electrode design. Peak position alone is insufficient to establish a specific electrochemical mechanism.
- Report the analysis settings: Specify the frequency range, regularization method, λ-selection procedure, numerical grid, axis convention, DRT normalization, and integration boundaries to support reproducibility and comparison across datasets.
- Integrate DRT into production QC: An electrochemical workstation with built-in DRT analysis enables automated pass/fail classification without operator electrochemical expertise.
9. Summary
Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT) analysis represents EIS data as a continuous distribution of impedance contributions over relaxation time. Using the formulation adopted in this article:
\[
Z(\omega) = R_\infty + \int_0^\infty \frac{y(t)}{1 + j\omega t} \, dt
\]
\(\gamma(\tau)\) is the DRT density with respect to relaxation time and has units of Ω·s⁻¹. The resistance contribution associated with a selected DRT feature is calculated as:
\(R_{\text{process}} = \int_{\tau_1}^{\tau_2} \gamma(\tau) d\tau\)
DRT analysis can reveal relaxation responses that overlap in a Nyquist plot without requiring a predefined equivalent circuit topology. Tikhonov regularization is commonly used to stabilize the inverse calculation, with the regularization parameter controlling the balance between spectral detail and sensitivity to noise.
DRT feature positions and integrated resistance contributions can support the interpretation of interphase-related, charge-transfer, and mass-transport responses. However, feature assignments are system-dependent and should be evaluated in the context of cell chemistry, operating conditions, data quality, and complementary electrochemical evidence. When used with compatible DRT analysis software, the IEST ERT7008 can support an integrated workflow for EIS acquisition, DRT reconstruction, regularization, feature selection, and resistance integration.
10. References
[1] T.H. Wan, M. Saccoccio, C. Chen and F. Ciucci, Influence of the discretization methods on the distribution of relaxation times deconvolution. Electrochim. Acta 184 (2015) 483–499.
[2] M. Saccoccio, T.H. Wan, C. Chen and F. Ciucci, Optimal regularization in distribution of relaxation times applied to electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. Chem. Mater. 26 (2014) 5916–5926.
[3] S. Dierickx, A. Weber and E. Ivers-Tiffée, How the distribution of relaxation times enhances complex impedance data interpretation. Electrochim. Acta 294 (2019) 355–365.
11. FAQ: Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT) Analysis
11.1 What is Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT) and how does it differ from Equivalent Circuit Model fitting?
Distribution of Relaxation Times (DRT) is a mathematical method that converts EIS frequency-domain data Z(ω) into a time-domain distribution function γ(τ), where each peak in γ(τ) represents one independent electrochemical process at its characteristic relaxation time constant τ. Unlike Equivalent Circuit Model (ECM) fitting, DRT analysis requires no prior assumption about circuit topology — the spectrum is recovered directly from the data by numerical inversion. This makes DRT particularly valuable for exploratory analysis of unknown systems, degradation diagnosis where the ECM topology may change with aging, and detection of processes that are invisible in the Nyquist plot because their time constants are too similar to resolve visually. The two methods are complementary: DRT reveals how many processes are active and where their time constants lie; ECM provides robust quantitative parameters once the circuit topology is known.
11.2 What is Tikhonov regularization and why is it needed for DRT analysis?
Tikhonov regularization is the most widely used algorithm for computing the DRT function γ(τ) from measured EIS data. It is needed because the mathematical inversion of Z(ω) to γ(τ) is an ill-posed problem: without constraints, small amounts of measurement noise in the EIS data produce arbitrarily large oscillations in the recovered γ(τ) spectrum, generating artifact peaks that do not correspond to real electrochemical processes. Tikhonov regularization adds a penalty term λ‖∇γ‖² to the optimization objective, which suppresses rapid variations in γ(τ) at the cost of some spectral resolution. The regularization parameter λ controls this trade-off: too large a λ merges nearby processes into one broadened peak; too small a λ retains noise-driven artifacts. Optimal λ is typically selected using L-curve analysis or generalized cross-validation.
11.3 How do you interpret DRT peaks in a lithium-ion battery EIS spectrum?
Each DRT peak identifies one electrochemical process by its position on the τ-axis and quantifies its impedance by its area. For lithium-ion batteries: peaks at τ < 10⁻⁵ s correspond to ohmic resistance (electrolyte, separator, leads); peaks at τ = 10⁻⁵–10⁻³ s correspond to SEI layer ion transport — SEI peaks grow with aging as the passivation film thickens; peaks at τ = 10⁻³–10⁻¹ s correspond to charge transfer kinetics at the electrode–electrolyte interface — these increase as active material degrades; peaks at τ > 10⁻¹ s correspond to solid-state diffusion of lithium ions within electrode particles. The area under each peak (in Ω) directly equals the resistance of the corresponding process — the same value that ECM fitting would assign to the RSEI, Rct, or equivalent circuit element.
11.4 How is the impedance of each process calculated from a DRT spectrum?
The impedance contribution of each process is the area under its DRT peak, calculated by integrating γ(τ) over the time constant range [τ₁, τ₂] associated with that peak: Rprocess = ∫ γ(τ) d(ln τ). Numerically, this is computed as a stepwise summation (SUMPRODUCT calculation) over the discretized γ(τ) values within the selected peak range. This operation yields a resistance value in ohms directly comparable to the corresponding ECM fitting parameter. The IEST ERT7008 software performs this integration automatically: users select the peak boundaries graphically, and the software returns the integrated peak area without manual spreadsheet calculations.
11.5 What electrochemical workstation features are required for DRT analysis?
Accurate DRT analysis requires three capabilities from the electrochemical workstation: (1) high-quality EIS acquisition — low noise, accurate phase measurement across the full frequency range (0.01 Hz to 100 kHz or broader), and data quality verification via Kramers–Kronig compliance testing before DRT processing; (2) sufficient frequency resolution — enough measurement points per decade (typically 6–10) to provide the data density needed for reliable inversion; (3) integrated DRT computation software with Tikhonov regularization, regularization parameter guidance, and peak integration — to perform the full EIS-to-DRT workflow without external software. The IEST ERT7008 electrochemical workstation integrates all three capabilities, enabling DRT analysis as part of standard EIS test protocols alongside charge-discharge cycling and cyclic voltammetry.
Subscribe Us
Contact Us
If you are interested in our products and want to know more details, please leave a message here, we will reply you as soon as we can.







